Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Rick Herbst's avatar

Borderline Interesting - this is great material. To set context, I have spent since 2008 watching Yarvin, aka Mencius Moldbug (if your readers are googling people’s names). That’s his pseudonym, or was, to be accurate. You’ve obviously done your homework and pulled the very important facts together for the reader to conclude in no uncertain terms that there are certainly no coincidences in play here.

What I would encourage ALL readers of this *excellent* article to do is remember this: Yarvin is NOT A POLITICAL SCIENTIST, nor a SOCIOLOGIST, nor ANYONE with ANY credentials except the gray matter between his ears. His “salvation plan” through NRx is sooooooooooo full of holes and lacks sooooooo many details he leaves to “just working themselves out” that I can knock him over with a feather in a light breeze. I have spent money going to schools to learn, in no uncertain terms, why things “are the way they are.” Yarvin has not. I will challenge him to duel opposing views any day of the week, and twice on Sunday. His target state of NRx is one where a pattern of “try it now” thinking emerges: Over and over, new “government-as-a-service” will be propagated, expand, have its moment, and fail. Just like the same corporations he models his dictator rule by.

I am getting into the weeds already. The point is, THINK OF HIM AS A RHETORICIST - NOT A VISIONARY. His one skill is selling you on baffling bullshit that masks inherent WEAKNESS in design. It is not our “future” - and I point out that most billionaires attribute their success to PURE LUCK feeding WELL OVER 50% of it. Yarvin just caught a willing fish in Thiel, and that is why Andressen and Musk and Bezos and several others are all sharing their cash with him.

In a stunning way, if you really follow all that money+power+logic to its logical end, the whole NRx movement is a huge waste of time that has been tried, failed, and leaves so many elements of government+society+people unaccounted for, it doesn’t deserve the title of being a “movement” at all. Full stop. Thanks for reading.

Expand full comment
Richard Bedingfield's avatar

Thank you for a riveting essay. I always comfort myself that at no time anywhere in the world has a system of pure intellectual governance ever survived for long. That is probably because 99.99 percent of those governed are not perfect thinkers and eventually bring it down. That applies to politics and religion. It is almost like the average wealth creating family going from rags to riches and back in three generations. Children of the privileged tend to rebel against their elders and lose their parent's work ethic. Musk is heading in that direction, as far as I can tell.

Expand full comment
19 more comments...

No posts